Hi father, this isn't really what I meant. Of course Mary plays personal roles within the redemption of Christ and within our personal lives and so forth. What I mean is that the rest of Apocalypse 12 would clearly refer to ages of the church and Mary does not positively gude ages of the church nor does her son through a direct revelatory presence and human history after the death of the last apostle.

I think the Marion faithful are the Church of Sardis the faithful remnant during the minor apostasy

Yes Father I think I agree with everything you say because I have heard the same thing people pretty much died the way that they have lived so that if a person has lived with an obstinency that they simply don't need forgiveness in any conceivable sense and can live as they want they are unlikely to change their mind in the face of death even if they encounter suffering because they will probably blame it on God rather than come to that senses we have a brother like that my wife's brother and we only hope to God that he will painted because he's bitterness and arrogance toward the church was very severe we only hope that he had a last-minute repentance

There is a profound way to look at the five loads and two fish as the seven sacraments and noting that heretics lose five sacraments that require the episcopet and retain only two sacraments baptism and marriage and these two fish are in the sea of chaos and Protestants are always in chaos of doctrine without the church

Well yes I think that's a good answer a person who knowingly rejects something that they believe to be true in their conscience out of arrogance and ill will and carries it unto death will not be saved that's true and hence if someone knows and their conscience that the Catholic church is true but does not make an effort to try to enter they will not be saying that's true In this regard to however we must realize that there are many non-catholic Christians who are not fully culpable for not being Catholic because they don't have enough information for really understanding or completely and or do not suspect her to be true because they have misinformation remember how dear blessed Bishop Fulton j Sheen talk about this There are maybe 100 people in the world that hate Catholic Church but there are millions who hate what they mistakenly believe the Catholic Church to be

Okay father I thank you for your response. I would never want to presume the Saint Thomas Aquinas did not have the unfathomable wisdom that he had nor similarly Saint Augustine. Nevertheless I would suggest a doctrine does develop and subsequently if Saint John Paul the second in modern times has taken aquinas's ideals and extended them into final impedance is not trying to denigrate aquinas's wisdom but to say that effectively what you are talking about that disposition must be taken unto death in order to be unforgivable because who knows maybe repentance is possible by the grace of God for example dearest same faustina talk to jesus's revelation that even unto the last millions of a second before death the heavenly father will call the sinner and say accept my mercy And I still think that we can suggest an apocalyptic meaning because it makes good sense it really does and I can give you my article for a fuller argumentation if you like thank you and I'm sorry if I come across as up as antagonistic God bless you